Decisions & Validation: demo-test-b-general

Artifact validation

project.yaml

No issues.

organization.yaml

No issues.

brand.yaml

warning required-field-missing: required field 'brand.name' is missing/empty (allowed while DRAFT)

Platform constraints (sitemap)

PASS -- no issues.

Schema map checks

PASS -- no issues.

Decision log

artifact_type: decision_log

# Decision Log — demo-test-b-general (TEST/DEMO DATA)

Part of a controlled A/B Build OS validation against
`demo-test-a-specialist`. See `docs/AB_TEST_COMPARISON.md` for the full
side-by-side analysis.

| Date | Decision | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-06 | Classified intake as Path D — 6 Amazon-style listings captured (gen-001 through gen-006), no brand/organization established. | Standing | intake-routing |
| 2026-09-06 | organization.yaml set to status: NOT_ESTABLISHED, per A/B test control condition — held identical to Test A. | Standing | organization skill |
| 2026-09-06 | Brand Direction drafted from aggregate evidence across all 6 products: no coherent category/audience throughline found across kitchen, electronics, fitness, home/office, pet, and home/garden items. positioning and target_audience both marked NOT YET CONFIRMED (weak inference only) rather than guessed, and brand.positioning was additionally flagged as a missing_critical_field during intake-routing -- a genuine connecting value proposition should be asked for directly. brand.name deliberately left unconfirmed. | Standing | brand skill |
| 2026-09-06 | Site Architecture drafted: 6 collections, one per category, matching product.identity.category groupings -- no forced merging of unrelated categories into a false shared collection. No subcategory nesting added despite 6 top-level groupings, since each holds only 1 product (depth should track catalog density, not be added preemptively). Passed shopify_platform_constraints_check.py, 0 errors. | Standing | shopify-ia skill |
| 2026-09-06 | Schema Map drafted: Tier-1 only (Product, CollectionPage), field references only, Organization omitted (NOT_ESTABLISHED), Offer omitted (no confirmed commerce data). Passed schema_validate.py, 0 errors. | Standing | schema-org skill |
| 2026-09-06 | No artifact in this project has been human-approved. All remain DRAFT/DIRECTION_DRAFT, below their respective human_approval gates per core/lifecycle.yaml. TEST/DEMO DATA only. | Standing | A/B test run |